[
    {
        "Variant name": "main",
        "Reviewer name": "Julie Digne <julie.digne@liris.cnrs.fr>",
        "Is master variant (boolean)": true,
        "Is variant deprecated (boolean)": false,
        "Title": "Smoke Rings from Smoke",
        "DOI": "10.1145/2601097.2601171",
        "Year": 2014,
        "ACM Keywords": [
            "Animation"
        ],
        "Topic {Rendering, Animation and Simulation, Geometry, Images, Virtual Reality, Fabrication}": "Animation and Simulation",
        "Co-authors from academia (boolean)": true,
        "Co-authors from industry (boolean)": false,
        "ACM Open Access (boolean)": false,
        "PDF on the authors' webpage / institution (boolean)": true,
        "PDF URL": "http://multires.caltech.edu/pubs/Smoke.pdf",
        "PDF on Arxiv or any openarchive initiatives (boolean)": false,
        "Arxiv/OAI page URL": "",
        "Project URL": "http://multires.caltech.edu/pubs/SRfS/",
        "Code available (boolean)": true,
        "If code not available, pseudo-code available (boolean)": false,
        "If pseudo-code, could the paper be trivially implemented? {0..4}": "",
        "Code URL": "https://dl.acm.org/ft_gateway.cfm?id=2601171&type=zip&path=%2F2610000%2F2601171%2Fsupp%2Fa140%2Dweismann%2Ezip&supp=1&dwn=1",
        "Code URL2": "",
        "MD5 sum (for archives)": "c2e4fb85aed6e26d56f80ebae737612c",
        "git/hg/svn commit hash or revision number": "",
        "MD5 sum (for archives) URL2": "",
        "git/hg/svn commit hash or revision number URL2": "",
        "Software Heritage permalink": "",
        "Software type {Code, Binary, Partial Code}": "Code",
        "Code License (if any)": "This implementation is provided by Albert Chern and comes with no warranty of fitness or performance either explicit or implied. Use for commercial purposes is explicitly prohibited without prior permission from the authors.",
        "Are the code authors explicit? (boolean)": true,
        "Build/Configure mechanism": "Not applicable (python, Matlab..)",
        "Dependencies": "matlab",
        "Does the software require paywall/proprietary software/material (boolean)?": false,
        "Does the code need data (not examples) (boolean)": false,
        "Nature of the data (pretrained model, LUT...)": "",
        "License of the data": "",
        "Able to perform a replicability test (boolean)": true,
        "If not able to perform a test, was it due to missing hardware/software? (boolean)": false,
        "Documentation score {0=NA,1,2,3}": 1,
        "Dependencies score {0=NA, 1,2,3,4,5}": 5,
        "Build/configure score {0=NA, 1,2,3,4,5}": 5,
        "Fixing bugs score (if any) {0=NA, 1,2,3,4,5}": 0,
        "Replicate paper results score {0=NA, 1,2,3,4,5}": 4,
        "Adaptability score to other contexts {0=NA, 1,2,3,4,5}": 5,
        "Time spent for the test (code download to first successful run, [0,10], 10min slots, 100min max)": 3,
        "Operating system for the test": "Linux",
        "Build instructions/comments": "Code works out of the box. Readme clearly states it misses some features and is less efficient. Adaptation to octave is very easy. It only requires commenting out two lines (lines 23-24 in PlotFilaments.m: l23: camproj perspective; l24 cameratoolbar).",
        "Misc. comments": "",
        "Software language": "Matlab / Mathematica / .."
    }
]